Intrusive Thoughts and Christianity: Why Your Faith Is Not Flawed
Your faith is not measured by the thoughts that visit you, but by the God you bring them to.
Yes. A Christian can have intrusive thoughts, and having them does not mean your faith is flawed. Here is what I have lived with and what has helped me.
You are in the middle of a prayer, or sitting in a church pew, or just starting to feel close to God. Then a thought hits that you never invited. It might be ugly, blasphemous, violent, or so far from who you are that it makes your stomach drop. Almost immediately a second thought follows: What kind of Christian thinks that?
That second thought does more damage than the first. This article is about the gap between the two, and about how intrusive thoughts and Christianity can exist in the same person without cancelling each other out.
What Intrusive Thoughts Actually Are
Intrusive thoughts are unwanted thoughts, images, or impulses that show up without permission. Researchers have found they are common, but they are more common in people who have suffered a trauma, and they are not a sign of bad character. What separates them from ordinary wandering thoughts is how they feel: they clash with your values, and they leave you distressed. If you want the clinical background first, Advancing Health explains it well.
For me this is not a passing season. I have dealt with intrusive thoughts since I was a child due to abuse and PTSD, I have better seasons and I have not so good seasons just like everyone else. I am not writing as someone who reads about them. I am writing as someone who has spent decades learning how to cope and overcome them.
Intrusive Thoughts and Christianity: Why Having Them Is Not a Sin
Many believers hold a fear that the thought itself is the offense. The Bible draws a line that most of us don't realize. Scripture speaks of what we nurse, welcome, and act on. It does not describe a thought that crashes into your mind against your will as a choice you made.
Romans 8:1 says there is no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus. The shame that comes with an intrusive thought is not coming from Him. It is an accusation, and you are allowed to treat it as one.
A thought you hate is evidence of a conscience that is working. A mind that was truly at peace with the content would not be tormented by it.
“Take Every Thought Captive” Does Not Mean What They Told You
Someone has probably quoted 2 Corinthians 10:5 at you. The verse talks about taking every thought captive to obey Christ, and it has been used as a stick against anxious people for a very long time.
In context, Paul is talking about tearing down arguments and ideas that set themselves up against the knowledge of God. He is describing a fight over what is true. He is not promising that a well disciplined Christian will never have an unwanted thought flash across their mind.
Using it that way turns a verse about truth into a verdict against people who are already suffering. If your brain generates thoughts you did not choose, that does not mean you failed to obey a verse. It means you are a human being with a brain.
The Judgment I Did Not Expect
The thoughts are hard, but the reactions have sometimes been harder. I expected skepticism from people outside my faith.
I did not expect to be handed the same message by fellow Christians, who told me that if I really trusted God, I would be free of this by now. That is a particular kind of harsh pain, because it came from people who were supposed to be loving, caring, nurturing and supportive.
Try applying that logic to something else. Nobody tells a person with asthma that they are only wheezing because they do not pray enough. We understand that a body can struggle without it being a moral failure. A mind deserves the same understanding.
This is something you have, usually as the result of some type of trauma done to you. It is not something you did.
It took me years of misery to accept that I did not owe those people my agreement. Well meaning or not, they do not get a vote on your faith. Do not let their voices become one more set of intrusive thoughts.
You already have enough to carry, and only two voices belong in that conversation: yours and God’s.
(I’ want to clarify this right away — if you’re on meds, stay on them. If you need help, go and get help. God gave us medicine for a reason, there’s nothing wrong with medication for our mental health. I am on medication, and it doesn’t diminish my faith or demonstrate a lack of faith because I’m taking something.)
What Helps Me When Intrusive Thoughts Hit
None of these are a permanent cure. These are what I reach for, I use them for intrusive thoughts, but also for anxiety, PTSD, and the days when everything feels like too much.
Name what is happening. When a thought hits, I tell myself plainly: this is an intrusive thought. It is not a plan, a desire, or a prophecy. Labeling it takes away some of its authority.
Stop wrestling with it. Arguing with the thought or trying to prove to yourself that you do not mean it usually feeds the cycle. Give it to God, let it be there, and let it pass.
Stop hiding. Like a lot of people, I learned to mask. Over time I realized I had pulled the mask on so tightly that nothing, including God, could get in. Find at least one safe person you can be honest with, and be honest with them.
Do not audit your faith in the middle of an episode. That is the worst possible time to decide whether you are really saved. Save the theology for a calmer hour.
Talk to Jesus, Not Just About Him
This is the part that changed the most for me, and it can be both the easiest and the hardest thing to do at the same time.
I started talking to Jesus the way I would talk to a person in the room with me. That is still prayer, but the mental shift that happened in me matters in this situation. Prayer can often felt like a list of requests you are submitting. Conversation feel like being known.
I could say the things I needed and was too ashamed to say anywhere else, and I could say them both badly and boldly.
Sometimes I speak out loud, and sometimes I do it silently, but I do not edit myself. I need to get what is in my head out of it. Left inside, the thoughts grow like an infection. Said to Him, they lose that. He does not flinch, judge, or send me a therapy bill.
This fits who the Bible says He is. Isaiah 9:6 calls Him “Wonderful Counselor.” If struggling minds were evidence of weak faith, it would be strange for Scripture to introduce Him that way. Matthew 11:28 invites the weary and burdened to come to Him.
It does not tell them to get their thoughts in order first, if that was the case then truly what is the point of calling on Jesus in our time of need?
Faith That Struggles Is Still Faith
The Bible is full of people who struggled. Elijah, right after a spectacular victory, sat under a tree and asked God to let him die (1 Kings 19). God did not rebuke him. He sent food, rest, and a quiet voice. Psalm 94:19 says that when anxiety was great within the writer, God’s consolation brought him joy. The father in Mark 9:24 cried out, “I do believe; help me overcome my unbelief!” and Jesus answered him with mercy.
Honest struggle is not the opposite of faith. Bringing it to God, again and again, on the days when it would be easier to give up, is faith. It takes more grit than most people will ever see.
If anxiety is part of your story too, I wrote about it here: Can a Christian Have Anxiety? What Paul Admitted About Fear
Further reading: 6 People in the Bible Who Struggled With Their Mental Health
Press Ctrl + P (Windows) or Cmd + P (Mac) to print this article or save it as a PDF.
Comments