top of page

Can Faith and Evolution Coexist? Faith With an Asterisk

1 day ago
6 min read

Where faith and science coexist, and where I draw the line

Religion has played an important role throughout human history. It shapes culture, behavior, identity, traditions, and worldviews, and it has long been a way to understand the world and explain natural phenomena. People have debated for years whether religion and evolution can coexist.


Because there is great variability within religious groups, and religious beliefs are highly personal, the topic is complex, with no black-and-white, one-answer-fits-all.


My personal experiences with religion, my observations of other people’s beliefs, and what I’ve learned in my studies have shown me that religion is an important part of human culture and behavior, and that it can (and needs to) coexist with evolution to an extent.


My Stand

Though I don’t like categorizing, because labels often don’t encompass the true variability of personal beliefs, I am a Biblically based, non-denominational Christian. My faith is highly important in my day-to-day life. My personal relationship with God is extremely important to me; I am part of a women’s Bible study group; and I edit and contribute to this publication.


I believe that Scripture is God-breathed, written by God through people. Everything in the Bible is meant to be there and is absolute truth. That said, translation errors can and have occurred, so being choosy about which versions you read is important, as is reading multiple versions (for many reasons). Studying the original or oldest manuscripts matters as well, something I have learned to love.


I believe Scripture is both literal and metaphorical, or at least has areas with multiple, correct interpretations. The things that fall outside the more literal side are often things that don’t matter for salvation, yet they are often what people focus on and argue about the most. That conflict is problematic, because it can make people lose sight of the bigger picture and weaken our calling to love others, despite our differences.


Science and Faith

Even with these views on Scripture, I believe science in general can coexist with Christianity. I believe a lot of science proves the existence of God and the incredible plan He has had for creation. Understanding the how of some of these processes doesn’t take away from the Creator who designed and implemented them; in fact, quite the opposite, it exemplifies Him even more. The more I learn, the more I am in awe of Him and His creativity, foresight, planning, and just the overall insanity of interconnected complex systems and everything it took to make them work.


Even non-believers can appreciate the absurdity of complex systems found in nature and their even more complex roles with each other. Throughout history, we have been fascinated by nature and natural processes, and many religions started from, or were influenced by, that fascination. There are processes outside of us, and both science and religion recognize them and attempt to explain them.


Variation in Belief

I’ve observed a lot of variation in religion and religiosity during my life. Some of my family are Christians who hold similar importance and practices, while other members are Christians in name only, if they have any religiosity at all. Both within Christianity and in other religions, I’ve noticed great variability in beliefs, practices, and importance in everyday life. It seems highly personal, in both experience and expression.


All the women in my Bible study group, for example, have different experiences with God and are at different points in their journey with Him. They hear Him differently and express their love and devotion differently. I’ll admit I don’t know many, if any, people who practice a religion other than a Christian denomination. However, I am familiar with other religions’ basic ideology, mostly from studying over the years and a recent World Religions class.


People are highly variable, even within groups that share similar beliefs, cultures, and languages, and that naturally extends to religious beliefs, practices, and personal importance. Even among people who share my faith and study the same Scripture, I’ve found differing views on some things, whether because we disagree or because one person has more experience or knowledge on a certain topic. Online, through Medium, I’ve read many other perspectives on Christianity and the Bible, which again show this variation and intimate nature.


Why We Look for Meaning

Humans are naturally curious, and we try to describe and explain what we don’t understand. Religion has been a way to do just that. It has also given people a sense of meaning, purpose, and a way to view the world; that view shapes our behavior and often dictates how we live our lives. Religious beliefs, practices, and traditions are passed down culturally, influencing individual and group behavior (Boyd et al., 2023, pp. 427-435), and they provide a sense of belonging and identity. Even people who aren’t religious are often influenced by religious traditions and cultural practices. Holidays like Christmas and Easter have religious origins but are widely celebrated regardless of personal belief.


Religion also regulates human behavior, which benefits the survival of the group and is important for cooperation (Boyd et al., 2023, pp. 435-443). I believe God gave us these aspects of religion for our benefit; we just have tried to take God out of the equation, hence the many different religions and religious practices. We are cognitively wired to look for God, for meaning in life, and for explanations of phenomena. More generally, one could argue we are cognitively wired to learn, cooperate, socialize, and regulate each other’s behavior for our own benefit and the group’s.


Coexisting With an Asterisk

Personally, I think certain aspects of evolution and religion can coexist. For me, they coexist in an asterisk sort of way, with stipulations and disagreements on certain things. There is some truth in microevolutionary mechanisms such as mutation, variation, recombination, genetic drift, gene flow, adaptation, and maybe speciation to an extent, though macroevolutionary concepts are a point of conflict.


I’m not alone in this. The National Center for Science Education [NCSE] and Thigpen et al. (2016; 2020) both touch on it. Others have a stronger belief in the coexistence of evolution and religion, and the type of religion seems to play a role (Heddy & Nadelson, 2012; NCSE, 2016; Pew Research Center [PRC], 2014; Thigpen et al., 2020). Still others disagree more strongly that the two can coexist at all (NCSE, 2016). Reconciling the two seems personal and individualized, easier for some than others, and it depends on how one defines these concepts and how one views or applies them.


While I may not agree with the concept of evolution as a whole, certain truths within it make it a concept that is here to stay and will be debated for many more generations. Even so, the world is a masterclass in conflicting concepts, ideas, and beliefs existing alongside one another without the conflict being, well, a conflict. You can recognize someone’s differing beliefs without condoning or supporting them, while still living beside them amicably and peacefully. So ultimately, on some level, religion and evolution can coexist.


Where That Leaves Us

Based on my personal experiences, my observations, and what I’ve learned in my studies, I believe religion is an important part of human culture, behavior, and identity. It gives people meaning, purpose, and a way to understand the world around them. On a personal level, my faith is integral to me and gives me hope for myself and for humanity. At the same time, scientific concepts like evolution continue to shape how people understand natural processes. While there are aspects of evolution that I and others disagree on, there is some truth to the processes it describes. Because of this, I believe evolution and religion don’t always have to exist in conflict.


Further, we live in a world filled with diverse beliefs, worldviews, and experiences, and we will never resolve every disagreement or conflicting viewpoint. It is important to learn to coexist with others who hold different views and beliefs than ours, and that makes the coexistence of religion and evolution possible. Everyone will reconcile these concepts differently. What matters is respecting one another and recognizing that complete agreement is not required to coexist.


© Maia V. Schmidt

Edited and fact-checked by Jane Isley


Explore More:

The Godless Tribe Myth: What the Pirahã Actually Believe A linguist called an Amazonian tribe “the godless tribe.” A closer look at what the Pirahã actually believe tells a different story about how people reach for something beyond themselves.


References:

  • Boyd, R., Silk, J. B., & Langergraber, K. (2023). How Humans Evolved (10th ed.). W. W. Norton.


  • Heddy, B. C., & Nadelson, L. S. (2012). A global perspective of the variables associated with acceptance of evolution. Evolution: Education and Outreach, 5, 412–418.


  • National Center for Science Education [NCSE]. (2016, January 22). The Creation/Evolution Continuum. NCSE.


Comments


bottom of page